Why Verification Matters for Housing Providers
Support animal letters carry real legal weight. Under the Fair Housing Act, a tenant who presents a valid support animal letter is entitled to a reasonable accommodation, meaning you cannot enforce a no-pets policy, charge a pet deposit, or deny housing based on the animal’s presence.
That protection is important and rightful. But fraudulent letters are a documented problem. Online services sell certificates, ID cards, and letters with no clinical evaluation involved. When a landlord unknowingly accepts a fake letter, it creates liability risks, fairness issues for other tenants, and conflict that can be costly to resolve.
Knowing how to verify a support animal letter is not about finding reasons to deny accommodations. It is about applying a consistent, lawful process that protects your property, your tenants, and your compliance standing.
What a Legitimate Support Animal Letter Contains
A valid support animal letter is a clinical document. It is not a certificate, a registration card, or a digital badge. The letter must come from a licensed mental health or medical professional and include specific information that can be cross-referenced and verified.
When you review a letter, look for these required elements.
- Provider credentials: The letter must include the clinician’s full name, professional license type (such as Licensed Professional Counselor, Licensed Clinical Social Worker, or Psychologist), license number, and the state in which they are licensed.
- Date of the therapeutic relationship: The provider must have an established relationship with the patient. A letter issued on the same day as a first contact is a red flag.
- Statement of disability: The letter must confirm that the tenant has a disability as defined under the Fair Housing Act. It does not need to name the diagnosis, but it must confirm that a qualifying disability exists.
- Nexus statement: The letter must connect the animal to the disability. The provider must state that the support animal is part of the tenant’s treatment plan or that the animal helps alleviate one or more symptoms of the disability.
- Provider signature: A wet or verified digital signature is required. A printed name with no signature is not sufficient.
- Contact information: A verifiable phone number, address, or email tied to the provider’s licensed practice must appear on the letter.
If any of these elements are missing, the letter is incomplete. You have the right to request a complete letter before granting an accommodation. You do not have to accept an incomplete document as sufficient.

How to Check Provider Licensing
Every state maintains a public licensing database for mental health professionals. These databases are free to use and allow you to confirm that the person who signed the letter holds an active, valid license in good standing.
To run a license check, go to your state’s licensing board website. Most states have separate boards for psychologists, licensed professional counselors, licensed clinical social workers, and marriage and family therapists. Search the provider’s name and license number. Confirm three things: the license is active, the license type matches what appears on the letter, and the license has not been disciplined or revoked.
The Association of State and Provincial Psychology Boards maintains a directory of state licensing boards at asppb.net, which can help you locate the correct board quickly. For non-psychology mental health licenses, the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services also maintains state-by-state resources through its behavioral health agency directories.
If the provider’s license cannot be found in the state database, that is a significant red flag. Do not assume the database search failed. Try alternate spellings and then follow up directly with the provider using the contact information on the letter.
Using Verification Tools and Documentation Portals
Manual license checks take time. For property managers overseeing multiple units, a documentation portal built for support animal verification can make the process faster and more consistent.
TheraPetic® Healthcare Provider Group, a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, operates an online verification portal specifically designed for housing providers. The portal allows landlords and property managers to verify TheraPetic® support animal documentation in real time. You can access it at go.mypsd.org.
The portal confirms that a letter was issued by a licensed clinical doctor within TheraPetic®’s clinical network, that the provider holds an active state license, and that the documentation was generated through a legitimate clinical review process rather than an automated or non-clinical system.
Using a structured support animal screening process like this one creates a paper trail for your records and removes the subjective judgment from the verification step. It also reduces your exposure to fair housing complaints by showing that you applied the same process to every request, regardless of the tenant or the animal.
Not every letter you receive will come through TheraPetic®. For letters from other providers, the manual license check process described above remains your primary verification tool. Document every step you take.
Red Flags That Signal a Fraudulent Letter
Fraudulent support animal letters are often easy to identify once you know what to look for. The following patterns consistently appear in documentation that does not hold up to scrutiny.
- No license number on the letter: Any licensed provider knows to include their license number. Its absence almost always indicates a non-clinical source.
- Generic or templated language: Phrases like “To Whom It May Concern, this letter certifies that the bearer requires an emotional support animal” with no individualized clinical language are hallmarks of bulk-generated documents.
- Same-day issuance after an online questionnaire: A clinical relationship cannot be established through a five-minute online form. Letters issued immediately after a digital intake survey are not clinically valid.
- Out-of-state provider with no telehealth disclosure: A provider licensed in one state can treat patients in another state through telehealth, but the letter should reference that the services were provided via telehealth. A letter signed by a provider in a different state with no such disclosure warrants closer review.
- The letter references a “registry” or includes a certificate: Support animal registries have no legal standing under the Fair Housing Act or any federal housing regulation. A legitimate letter does not mention registration and does not come with a numbered certificate or ID card.
- No nexus statement: If the letter only states that the tenant has a disability but does not connect the animal to the disability, it is incomplete and potentially fraudulent. A real clinician will always include the therapeutic relationship between the patient and the animal.
- Provider cannot be reached: Call the phone number on the letter. If no one answers, no voicemail exists, or the number is disconnected, the documentation is likely fraudulent.
Document every red flag you identify. If you decide to request additional information from the tenant, do so in writing and keep a copy for your records.

What You Can and Cannot Ask Under the Fair Housing Act
The Fair Housing Act sets clear boundaries on what housing providers may request when a tenant asks for a support animal accommodation. Understanding those boundaries protects you from a fair housing complaint.
You CAN ask for documentation confirming that the tenant has a disability as defined by the Fair Housing Act. You CAN ask for documentation explaining the need for the support animal, meaning the nexus between the disability and the animal. You CAN verify the provider’s license independently. You CAN contact the provider to confirm the letter’s authenticity, using the contact information on the letter.
You CANNOT ask for the tenant’s medical records, diagnosis name, or treatment history. You CANNOT require a specific form or format for the letter. You CANNOT charge a pet deposit or pet fee for a support animal. You CANNOT impose breed or weight restrictions on a support animal. You CANNOT require the animal to be trained or certified, as training is not a legal requirement for support animals under the Fair Housing Act.
HUD’s guidance on reasonable accommodations under the Fair Housing Act, available through the HUD Office of Fair Housing and Equal Opportunity, is the authoritative source on these questions. Bookmark it. When in doubt, consult it before taking action.
If your property has an HOA board, share this guidance with the board. HOA boards are held to the same Fair Housing Act standards as individual landlords. Inconsistent enforcement at the board level creates the same liability as inconsistent enforcement by a property manager.
Handling Unverifiable or Incomplete Documentation
What do you do when a letter cannot be verified? Start with a written request for additional information. Give the tenant a reasonable deadline, typically ten to fourteen business days, to provide a complete letter or to authorize contact with the provider.
If the provider cannot be reached and the tenant cannot provide updated documentation, you may have grounds to deny the accommodation. But proceed carefully. Document every step you took to verify the letter and every attempt you made to contact the provider. Consult with a fair housing attorney before issuing a formal denial.
Never deny an accommodation based solely on your intuition or because the animal is a breed you find concerning. The denial must be grounded in the inability to verify that the required elements of the accommodation request have been met.
You can also use a third-party support animal verification service as part of your process. These services can run license checks, flag documentation issues, and provide a documented audit trail that supports your decision-making on both approvals and denials.
Building a Consistent Review Process for Your Property
Consistency is your best legal protection. If you apply a different standard to one tenant’s support animal request than you do to another’s, you risk a disparate treatment claim under the Fair Housing Act, even if your intent was not discriminatory.
Build a written policy for handling support animal accommodation requests. The policy should specify what documentation you require, how you verify it, how long the review process takes, and who is responsible for making the determination. Every tenant who requests an accommodation should move through the exact same process.
Train everyone who handles accommodation requests, including leasing agents, property managers, and HOA board members. A leasing agent who tells an applicant that support animals are not allowed has just created a fair housing liability, regardless of what your written policy says.
Review your policy annually. HUD issues updated guidance periodically, and staying current with landlord resources on support animal law ensures your process reflects the most current legal standards as of 2026.
TheraPetic® Healthcare Provider Group supports housing providers by making clinical documentation transparent and verifiable. As a 501(c)(3) nonprofit, TheraPetic®’s mission is to ensure that legitimate support animal documentation is accessible and defensible for both tenants and the housing providers who review it. If you have questions about verifying a specific letter or need support building a review process, reach out to the team at help@mypsd.org or call (800) 851-4390.
You can also visit go.mypsd.org to access the TheraPetic® verification portal directly and confirm documentation status in real time.
Written By
Ryan Gaughan, BA, CSDT #6202 , Executive Director
TheraPetic® Healthcare Provider Group • About • LinkedIn • ryanjgaughan.com
Clinically Reviewed By
Dr. Patrick Fisher, PhD, NCC , Founder & Clinical Director • The Service Animal Expert™
Editorial Review
This article was reviewed by Dr. Patrick Fisher, PhD, NCC on October 28, 2026 for accuracy, currency, and clarity. Content is updated when laws or guidance change.